2011-12-03 01:47 pm
Entry tags:

(no subject)

Slate has an interesting article on the rise of the angry commenter on the Internet:

http://www.slate.com/articles/life/roiphe/2011/12/what_s_wrong_with_angry_commenters_.html

This made me think: do you guys see fandom as having more, less, or about the same angry commenters than the internet in general? Are there differences between the two types? Why do you think that is?
2011-11-07 02:46 pm

new Swordspoint fic by Ann

[personal profile] just_ann_now has written a new story. in the Swordspoint verse. How Richard met Alec, and what came after. It's a first time fic, and a first night, which means this fic is not for the kiddies. But neither is it for people who are looking for a PWP or anything too explicit. Somehow Ann walks that line I am never quite able to toe: explicit in the sense of not fading to black, but never graphic - I don't think she actually describes anything beyond a kiss - while still managing to be incredibly erotic.

More than that, she has completely nailed Alec's voice. The abandonment. The shyness laced with defiance. Richard's, too, but Alec here is precisely how I imagine him in my head.

All in all, a very nice read. Those of you who like this fandom are missing out if you don't give it a read.

http://community.livejournal.com/_riverside/65085.html
2011-10-21 12:56 am

(no subject)

I had an "OMG, how did I miss this?" moment just now, when I read a post over at [personal profile] edoraslass's journal. Apparently Lady Branwyn had a birthday a few days ago. I know I can be really slipshod about wishing people a happy day, but Branwhy is a good friend and I like to recognize the anniversary of when she entered the world. Several years ago, when we were living in the same city, we were part of a dinner club with other local Tolkien fans/fanfic writers. I also got to know Lord Branwyn and her adorable (if skittish!) kitten. Good times. I hope she is still living it up.

I usually recommend a story by the person on birthdays like this, and so I looked around her SOA page, where she posts most of her work. So many good things to choose from (and so many that I am behind on reading), but one jumped out immediately: The Long Race. Before his wedding to Eowyn, Faramir must prove himself. Not really humor or drama or any other typical genre, but with camaraderie and cheek to spare - it makes me grin just remembering it. Do yourself a favor and read it, if you haven't already.
2011-10-19 09:20 pm

(no subject)

Read more... )

This picture is the footer over at the FB page for Lord of the Rings: War in the North (a video game). Any guess who/what the guy with the glowy staff is supposed to be? The only thing I can think is Radagast, which would just be wrong. Ideas?
2011-10-16 03:18 pm

speculative fiction vs. fan fiction

Over at Cecile's poll on speculative fiction (h/t Werecat), she asks first how many people write speculative fiction, and second what other of several related activities you do. One of those "others" is that you write fanfiction.

That caught me offguard, because to me fanfic in my fandoms can be speculative fiction. My fiction usually isn't because I tend to focus on different apsects of the universe than the speculative parts (race/class/gender issues, theodicy by any other name, family drama, etc.) but I also have read peoples' fan fic that is every bit as much speculative fiction as published authors. Werecat jumps to mind as a good example of that. Or Thundera Tiger. I'm sure I could come up with others.

So what do you think? Is fanfic properly separated out from SpecFic?

(P.S.: For more on the genre, read this.)
(P.P.S.: Do take the poll if you like. It was quick, painless, and seemed written by a genuine fan [no bad stereotypes, etc.])
2011-09-25 12:37 am
Entry tags:

Lord of the Rings a banned book

This week is banned book week, and apparently Lord of the Rings is on the list. That... amuses me, and leaves me feeling confuzzled. What's so objectionable about Tolkien?

http://www.ala.org/ala/issuesadvocacy/banned/frequentlychallenged/challengedclassics/index.cfm

In honor, I encourage everyone reading this to post the passage that you think would get it banned. What countercultural, challenging to the PTB but inspiring to the rest of us bit of Tolkien do you think would put it on such a list? (Other Tolkien books welcome as well.) And please leave me a link in the comments section, so I don't miss it.
2011-09-06 09:28 pm

(no subject)

I was listening to The Devil Went Down to Georgia and had a crazy thought: filk it to tell the one-on-one fight between Morgoth and Fingolfin as a battle of songs. It could really work, but I'm scared to try it because everything I try to write comes out feeling very leaden these days.

I'm tucking the nuzgul away, though, because I think it could be a lot of fun. In any event, imagining the scene is kind of nice.
2011-09-05 04:14 am

thoughts on "my" 'verse

I'm up late (or early) because I can't sleep again. Probably not the best time for blogging, I know. But [personal profile] rabidsamfan has a pretty interesting poll going on and I wanted to get my thoughts down. Do go vote in that poll, btw, if you haven't already.

RSF asked whether we ever cry at our old fic. My first thought was that she meant she read an old story and it was so bad, she was literally reduced to tears. I'm often ashamed of my old stuf, but never that much. Turns out though she meant something else entirely. Are we ever reduced to tears by the sad or dramatic or whatever stuff that we wrote?

I've often described my fanfic-writing like journalism. See, I have this really involved world playing out like a movie in my mind. There are some corners that are really well imagined and other corners that I haven't discovered all the details. But it's all there to be discovered. And it's all a reflection of me because ultimately "my" world is a reflection of my own self. I think about something, some theme or even some sensation, and somewhere there is a character that jumps up and it's obvious that this character's experience is pertinent to what I'm thinking about. But I don't dream up the story; it's just there. The trick is finding a POV, a snippet that I can unravel enough so it's not just reality but there's an actual narrative to it, a plot structure that functions as literature. In many ways, my private fantasy world which is the backdrop for my fanfic is more "real" than reality. More potent, closer to the ideal than the messy world with all of its frustrating details that can get in the way of a good story.

Why shouldn't I cry at that? My stories are snippets of a world that I hope has more pathos than reality because the details I am aware of are the ones that matter to the issue I want to work with. And I cry at the news, at the horrible things people do to each other. In a very weird way I care about my characters. Yeah, I know they're not alive, I'm not crazy or anything, but in a very real sense they are alive to me. Sometimes more alive than actual people I know in RL.

Incidentally, this is why it's so hard for me to write longer-length pieces. Think about that scene in The Hours where Ed Harris's character talks about trying to capture all the details of a single moment in time. It's impossible, and developing a larger story-arc is that much more impossible. It already feels like I am reducing the situation, to mention this detail and not that one. Fanfic for me isn't constructive, it's reductive, and at a certain point it no longer captures even the basics of my world. It's not laziness. There's a reason why my stories are usually less than 5,000 words and are the results of months of mental percolation, until they basically write themselves.

So to answer RSF's question: of course I cry over my stories if they're sad. They are in many ways more real than reality, at least to me.
2011-09-04 03:10 pm

(no subject)

From [personal profile] mrowe:

1. Reply to this post with "RAINBOWS", and I will pick five of your icons.
2. Make a post (including the meme info) and talk about the icons I chose.
3. Other people can then comment to you and make their own posts.
4. This will create a never-ending cycle of icon glee

Btw, please specify LJ or DW icons - I can do either, but will assume LJ unless you tell me otherwise...
2011-08-29 10:51 am

Fic Rec: Five Moves that Denethor and Faramir Never Made

Over at LJ, [profile] mraltariel wrote chess!fic. A five-drabble series featuring Denethor, Faramir, a smidgen of Gandalf, and of course the game of kings. Highly recommended.

Five Moves that Denethor and Faramir Never Made
2011-08-24 11:54 pm

(no subject)

Over at FB, journalist Nicholas Kristoff wrote,

I'm taking my eldest son to begin college tomorrow, and then I'm headed for Libya. What should I bring, other than my flak jacket & helmet? Any suggestions for most appropriate book or DVD to while away any firefights? Any other useful accoutrements you suggest for a Libyan trip?


I suggested the best five-book trilogy ever written for its mix of humor and adventure. But the comment got me thinking: what book would you recommend for a fictional character in dire straits? I mean, we do have a few examples of book-worms. Picard and Data have a thing for hard-boiled detectives and Shakespeare; SVU's Detective Munch shows a proclivity for public intellectuals like Noam Chomsky; and I'm sure there are others. And then you have Hermione, first-rate nerd and Muggle - I wonder what books she was carrying around in her enchanted handbag during Deathly Hallows? Not reference works but stuff to keep up her spirits.

So... just what books would you recommend to some fictional character facing a situation like Mr. Kristoff? And why? I'd be interested to know.
2011-08-24 10:30 pm

The Closer

I've been watching old episodes of The Closer in a spurt of last-of-summer freedom tonight. In this case it's a downloaded version of the third season, which ends with two double-episode sets - a Christmas, and the season finale about the murder of a lawyer (it's a rare episode where the case actually goes to trial). In downloaded form these episode sets are 12-13 and 14-15, respectively.

The thing is, the timeline gets a bit screwy here. It's at the end of the season finale that Brenda agrees to put hers and her affianced's house on the market. This is a major plot point - it's a mark of trust in their future that Brenda is finally willing to make this step. The Christmas special begins with a real estate broker showing their house, which would suggest that the Christmas special is set after the season finale, chronologically. It was also broadcast last. I can see why the download would order the season finale last, since it makes the most emotional sense of that season's characterization arcs and so on.

Only... not so much. The Christmas special has a scene where Brenda has to get a suspect drunk. Fritz objects to this because the suspect has a history of substance abuse (both drug and alcohol), but Brenda decides to go on with the drinking since they are trying to prevent a future crime and need information out of them. What struck me was Brenda's and Fritz's interaction over the booze. If she already knew that Fritz was a recovering alcoholic (revealed in the season episode) then she's being incredibly callous. She might still decide to go on with the plan, but I don't think even she would brush off his concerns. I also think Fritz would be much more upset with her than he was. Fritz can get upset quite well; in that episode he's given Brenda the evil eye over how much money she is spending carelessly, lying to her dad, and even over not helping him load their suitcases into the RV.

I know, this is a little thing, and I probably shouldn't complain. Still, the timeline issue irks me. It left me scratching my head on how to situate things in my mind.
2011-08-15 09:30 am

mememe

Nabbed from [profile] rubynye and others:

If I made Cinderella, the audience would immediately be looking for a body in the coach.
— Alfred Hitchcock
When I write a story, what do you immediately look for?
2011-08-02 12:11 am

SSP: Biography of Sauron for SWG folk

As I've mentioned, this month I was invited to write the biography for the Silmarillion Writers Guild. That bio is now available here:

Marta's SWG Biography of Sauron

In honor of the Akallabeth in August theme I chose to look at Sauron's backstory. Most people know him as the arch-villain of The Lord of the Rings, and he is of course that character, but he also has a really interesting backstory in The Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales. So I looked at what some of those stories tell us about him. Thanks to Dawn Felagund for the help copy-editing this.

For the interested, here are some of my other stories dealing with Sauron and Sauron's affects on others:

  1. "Ea" - ft. Sauron + Celebrimbor, Second Age Eregion
  2. "Fire and Smoke - ft. OC Numenoreans, last days of Numenor
  3. "The Gift of Men" - Tar-Miriel's POV, last days of Numenor
  4. "King's Men" - OC Easterling, Second Age
  5. "Respite" - Khamul's POV, late third age
2011-07-30 01:59 am

fannish stuff

A few fannish points of interest:

#1. Celeritas wrote me a ficlet as a mathom for her birthday. It's wonderful! Tea-time conversation between Bilbo and Boromir in Rivendell. I snorted out loud at least twice (that bit about Boromir not having learned Bilbo's father's name was inspired). Celeritas really captured two of my favorite characters' demeanor so well, and the whole interaction left me smiling like a loon.

Boromir's Education Begins Early

#2. SWG bio is completed and sent off. I'll post a link when it's publicly posted in a few days. Whenever I do this I get a newfound admiration for Oshun, who does this every month. Once a year or however regularly I get to do it is exhuasting - and yet I find myself wanting to do it more regularly.

#3. I taught the Ring of Gyges on Thursday, a story from Plato's Republic that critiques our idea of justice because (Glaucon argues) if you had a gold ring that would make you invisible you would steal things and act unjustly all the time, because you knew you wouldn't get caught. Shades of Gollum after he just found the ring. I pointed it out to my class and we had a good discussion of which story was correct. Would everyone steal if they knew they wouldn't get caught, or just those who had some weakness in their character? (Neither Frodo nor Bilbo go off like Gollum when they first inherited the ring.)

#4. Doing research for the SWG bio, I stumbled across yet another heart-rending detail about the dark religion Sauron instigated on Numenor:

Thereafter the fire and smoke went up without ceasing; for the power of Sauron daily increased, and in that temple, with spilling of blood and torment and great wickedness, men made sacrifice to Melkor that he should release them from Death. And most often from among the Faithful they chose their victims; yet never openly on the charge that they would not worship Melkor, the Giver of Freedom, rather was cause sought against them that they hated the King and were his rebels, or that they plotted against their kin, devising lies and poisons. These charges were for the most part false; yet those were bitter days, and hate brings forth hate.


It's that last bit that really has me reeling. So not only were they sacrificed to a false god, not only was the whole system set up by someone who was using the religion to drive the Numenoreans toward destroying themselves, but on top of that they had to be named traitors or kin-slayers as well because it wasn't enough to say they were heretics? Just... damn. There is level upon level of yuckiness built into there.

(And you know that latest bit will inspire a fic one of these days. My muses are already working overtime on it. Just how many pieces can one passage inspire?)
2011-07-24 01:57 am

(no subject)

Saw the newest HP movie this afternoon. I have promised myself not to indulge in the many thinky thoughts bouncing around my head until I finish my SWG bio, but three things need to be said outright:

1. kudos to the studio for treating this like part II - not a sequel. I loved how much it was just a continuation of the last movie.

2. the epilogue apparently feels like a tag-on of the worst sort to me, whether it was in print or film. I still wish they had cut off after the battle, and maybe used the time to develop the aftermath a bit more.

3. GO NEVILLE! I was fighting whooping out loud at points. Seriously, that's my boy! Er, man, now.

cut for spoilers )

More soon. Hopefully.
2011-07-23 01:42 pm

happy Vladurday!

I honestly don't know why Vladurday pictures (a common meme over at PunditKitchen.com) are so amusing, but they often are.

Read more... )

This just made me smile...